Why We Make So Many Ads for One Brand
After thousands of ads, I know one thing for sure: nobody can reliably predict which concept will win. The practical answer is to make enough good ads to find it.
You cannot predict the winner
After working through thousands of ads, here is what I know: nobody can consistently predict which ad will win. You can have a favorite concept. You can think one hook looks stronger than everything else. But until the ads run, you do not know what the audience will respond to.
That is why I make so many concepts for a single brand. The goal is not to create random variations for the sake of volume. The goal is to produce enough good, distinct ideas that we give ourselves a real chance of finding a winner.
One product can support many angles
For this unofficial concept work, I built a wide range of formats around the same product. That included a meme ad, a text-on-skin concept, a video animation, a “don’t buy this” angle, an “X reasons why” format, price anchoring, a review-led ad, and a benefits-focused concept.
I also made an exploded view, a science headline, a report card, a bento grid, a road sign, and a check-style concept. Each one presents the product differently without changing the product itself.
The takeaway: Stop trying to predict one perfect ad. Make enough strong concepts to let the market show you which one wins.
Change the delivery, not just the wording
The animation concept took another route. It showed the problem through a simple story: the sun is blazing, the runner is sweating, a sticky sugar drink is not helping, and plain water still leaves them feeling flat. Sweat takes salt, so the solution is to put the salt back.
From there, the ad introduces a citrus salt stick with zero grams of sugar, lemon-lime flavor, and sodium. The runner mixes it up, gets back in the race, and closes with the line, “Stay salty with element, put a smile on your face.”
That concept is different from a review, a meme, or a price anchor. It uses rhythm, animation, and a clear product story. I do not need to guess whether it will beat every static concept. I need to make it well, put it into the mix, and let performance answer the question.
That is the process: create many good ads, cover genuinely different formats, and keep looking for the one the audience chooses.
Want this done for you?
Book a free strategy call and we will show you exactly where the growth is hiding in your account.
Book a Free Strategy Call