← All articles

Why Excluding Existing Customers From Meta Ads Can Be a Mistake

Are you excluding existing customers from your Meta ad campaigns? You might be making a significant error. While it seems counterintuitive, sometimes including them can actually boost your overall campaign performance.

The Common Practice and a Potential Pitfall

If you are currently excluding existing customers from your prospecting Meta ad campaigns, you might be making a huge mistake. I've observed this in many ad accounts. For example, in one particular prospecting campaign, we intentionally excluded all customers who had purchased in the last six months. This strategy worked quite well for that specific ad account.

We were able to spend much more money on new audiences compared to what we typically would, and the ROAS was still pretty good. Now, of course, the return on ad spend for engaged audiences and existing customers is almost always going to be much higher. That's a given. However, in this scenario, our primary focus was not on maximizing the ROAS from existing customers, but rather on increasing our spend on new customer acquisition. We were looking to scale our efforts on bringing in fresh leads and sales, and for that, the reported ROAS was exactly what we needed.

Why One Success Doesn't Mean Universal Application

Here's the critical takeaway: the fact that this strategy worked successfully on one ad account does not automatically mean you should implement it in every single one of your ad accounts. This is a crucial point that I constantly emphasize. I test various approaches across different accounts, and what works wonders for one often performs poorly or even worse for another. Just because a tactic yielded positive results once doesn't guarantee it will work every single time.

Label: Testing is Key

You need a robust strategy and a clear understanding of your specific account's dynamics. There isn't a universal blueprint for Meta ads. While I'm all for testing new approaches and I'm actively experimenting with this exclusion strategy in other ad accounts where I believe it could yield better results, it's vital to recognize the variability. This leads to a broader discussion about what truly works on Meta ads. There isn't just one magic bullet or a single tactic that guarantees success. Instead, there are multiple strategies and approaches that work for different ad accounts because different ad accounts, with their unique audiences and histories, behave differently.

My Recommendation: Test, Don't Assume

So, what should you keep in mind? Test different things. Experiment with your audience exclusions, your targeting, and your creative. But always remember this fundamental truth: there is no single, one-size-fits-all blueprint for Meta advertising success. What works for one client or one campaign might not work for another. Continuous testing and adaptation based on your specific results are the only paths to consistent growth.

Related services
Facebook Ads AgencyMeta Ads AgencyShopify Marketing Agency

Want this done for you?

Schedule a free strategy call and we will show you exactly where the growth is hiding in your account.

Schedule a Call